Lower KS2 scores in MATs aren’t a judgement on academy programme, says DfE

Janet Downs's picture

‘MAT performance data should not be used to infer performance of the MAT system as a whole,’ the Department for Education says in its 2019 report on multi-academy trust performance in Key Stage 2 tests.

64% of 11-year-olds in MATs reached the expected standard in the combined reading, writing and maths measure.  The national average of all state-funded mainstream primary schools is 66%.  At MAT level, just over half (53%) didn’t reach the national average.

Hence the warning not to use the figures to attack the academies programme.  After all, academization, especially within a multi-academy trust is, trumpeted as a way of raising performance not lowering it.

There are valid reasons for treating these results with caution*.  MATs with fewer than three schools are excluded from the data as are academies which have been in a MAT for less than three years.  Progress measures are ‘in-year relative measures which, combined with the changing composition of MATs each year mean they should not be compared over time.’   The proportion of sponsored mainstream academies, those which were often inadequate before becoming academies, is ‘higher in MATs measures than across all academies.’

Comparing the overall MAT score with the overall state-funded mainstream score is not comparing like-for-like.

However, if the figures had shown the overall MAT score was higher than the national average, would the DfE have been so reticent?  It’s likely the figures would have been hailed as ‘proof’ that academies were better than the much-maligned local authority-maintained schools.


CORRECTION 16 December 09.22:  Grammar error in headline corrected



*See methodology document here.

Share on Twitter Share on Facebook

Be notified by email of each new post.


John Mountford's picture
Sat, 14/12/2019 - 12:53

The DfE, like the rest of the government and most of the media, has failed ordinary people. We have the insight into what the political interference in our state education system has caused. These institutions are perpetuating a falsehood, that people matter. If enough of us who understand and share this insight come together, we can do what is needed to secure a better, fairer and more hopeful future for us and the planet. This is not the time for sitting on our hands. Nor is it the time to stop demanding greater accountability from public servants.

The DfE is corrupt to the core. Shameful!

Gove, his conservative predecessors as SoS for Education (aided by Tony Blair) and a partisan, lazy, lying media set in train events that have all but destroyed quality education for all. It's time for parents and schools to call an end to this destruction of democracy.

Our children's futures are about more than a score.

Add new comment

Already a member? Click here to log in before you comment. Or register with us.